Head-to-Head Comparison

Alice's CottagevsSimply B Vermont

SpecAlice's CottageSimply B Vermont
Primary activityCat Toy ManufacturerCat Toy Manufacturer
Catnip originCatnip"B Happy" proprietary blend
Herb quantityLow (5g)Varies by toy
Herb Duration3-6 months1–3 months
Herb blendsCatnip onlyBlend of herbs
Creative DesignNoNo
FabricCottonFleece, upholstery canvas, felted wool
Vegetable-based DyesNoneNot specified
Biodegradable?NoPartial – Mixed materials
Refillable?NoNo
PersonalizableNoNo
Made inUSAUSA (Vermont)
Price / toy~$7.50$9.75–$12.99
HandmadeYesYes
Alice's Cottage
Cat Toy as a Primary ActivityOrganic CatnipHeavy FillingLong LastingActive on 90% of catsCreative DesignCotton FabricVegetable-based DyesBiodegradableRefillablePersonalizableMade in FranceHandmade
Company summary
  • Handmade catnip toys
  • Creative cat toys
  • Handmade in the USA
Strengths
  • +Handmade catnip toys.
  • +Creative line of cat toy products.
Limitations
  • −Some products include polyester fiberfill.
  • −No customization.
  • −Small fill.
Simply B Vermont
Cat Toy as a Primary ActivityOrganic CatnipHeavy FillingLong LastingActive on 90% of catsCreative DesignCotton FabricVegetable-based DyesBiodegradableRefillablePersonalizableMade in FranceHandmade
Company summary
  • Woman-owned independent brand
  • Handmade boutique-style alternative
  • Good product variety
Who it's for
  • •Feline owners who value handmade quality, non-responder-friendly blend, varied shapes and fabrics. Indie pet store shoppers, Etsy browsers, small-business supporters.
Strengths
  • +Handmade and boutique-oriented.
  • +Good product variety.
  • +Appeals to buyers who want artisan-style toys.
Limitations
  • −No customization.
  • −Less focused on a single best-in-class flagship product.

See how Ponoto compares

Ponoto specializes in premium catnip toys made in France — see how it compares to Alice's Cottage and Simply B Vermont individually.

Ponoto vs Alice's CottagePonoto vs Simply B VermontBrowse all comparisons

More comparisons